An Update On This Blog Regarding Posting Comments

I have received complaints about some people using the comment section who do not seem to stick to the subject but run all over the place posting about things that have no relevance to what the discussion is about. This has caused some people not to make a comment because they feel that it gets lost among those non relevant comments.

There have also been some comments that amount to ad hominem attacks on other people. These do not discuss the issue raised by the blog but attack the person making the comment. I do not feel these add to the knowledge of people who are along with me trekking toward the truth.

Then at times we have the yelling – where some people feel they have to write line after line in caps as if somehow we cannot read lower caps. I have asked people to refrain from doing that but my requests seem to fall like seeds on cement.

There have also been complaints about people who want to post several comments to one blog rather than responding like most people do in one comment putting their thoughts together and posting.

The idea for the blog is that we discuss things. We don’t run far afield although suggestions and references to other matters I may have discussed in the past such as problems with the FBI, the Justice System, race relations and the like are always welcome. Along with that citing other opinions and providing the site to them for others to pursue further research is also fine.

I want the blog to be a free flowing as possible as if we were in a discussion group where everyone has a chance to speak without some people hogging the discussion or going far off topic for a lengthy period or yelling. The question I face is how to make this happen. In the past I tried to review each comment prior to it being published but I found that hard especially since I have other things to do and more so now because my six-year-old grandson likes to hang around with his grandfather from the time he wakes him up until bed time.

So I am reluctant to return to doing that. But if need be I may be forced to do it. Or perhaps rather than restricting everyone I will just put any offender into a place I found myself in when in high school too many times called “jug” for a limited period of time as is done on Twitter.

I am asking for the following:

  1.  No more yelling. Make comments without capitalization.
  2.  No more hogging. Try to get all your thoughts into one post.
  3.  Be concise in your thoughts. F. Scott Fitzgerald who knew something about writing once wrote a letter and at the end he added: “I am sorry my response is so long but I’ve been rushed lately and haven’t had the time to put my thoughts together and write a more concise letter.”   On second thought maybe it was James Joyce who said it. In other words, even though in Dedham they have the James Joyce Ramble, try not to ramble on when you write. As Professor Strunk said we should all seek: “cleanliness, accuracy, and brevity in the use of English.”
  4. I try to limit my posts to six to seven hundred words. I should do better and bring them down to 500. No comment should exceed that length.
  5. Of course, you may respond once if you are referred to in another comment but only briefly and directly.
  6. No more ad hominem attacks.  Discuss the issue. Don’t discuss the person writing the comment.

I suggest if we follow those suggestions we my learn more from each other. Let’s see if it works.

 

 

13 thoughts on “An Update On This Blog Regarding Posting Comments

    1. JPC : There’s a 9 – 0 Supreme Court Case that dealt with that issue involving the St. Patrick’s Day Parade in South Boston that dealt with that issue. Look it up.

  1. What Honest Abe said goes for me, too.

    Regarding jug: Now you’ve got me wondering how many times I got it. I can count the instances on one hand…I think!

  2. Hello Matt, Mark Russo, English teacher at Boston Latin School would’ve been very proud of the orderly content of today’s Posting Instructions posted on today’s Blog by you! I really enjoy reading the postings appearing daily on your blog, both pro and con , and hope all participants will adhere to your wishes. Hope all is well in the Connolly Clan and all are staying safe! Slainte ☘️

    1. JRC:

      Always nice to hear from you. Think of you and your family often with pleasurable memories. Obviously we’ll differ in thinking of things. Wasn’t that something we learned as little tykes at Michael J? A little later as we moved on we were told never to discuss sports, religion or politics if we wanted to avoid fights but despite the good advice we never heeded it because we knew we were right.

      Speaking of sports I recall sitting in your bedroom on Old Colony Ave looking at what seemed to be 8 × 11 photographs of the Red Sox including Bobby Doer, Johnny Pesky, Dom DiMaggio and Ted William’s. Those were the days we knew every player. Now all I know about them is they still play at Fenway Park and are owned by an outsider.

      Good to hear from you. Hope you and E and the progeny are well. I miss R. Stay safe. Thanks for reading and the support.

      Slainte, Matt

  3. Sounds like a great plan, Matt. I will adhere to it. And thanks for being an excellent blog master.

  4. You are remiss in using the term “jug” without explanation, which would have little meaning to those who did not attend a Jesuit Catholic high school. A search of an online Merriam-Webster Dictionary is little help:

    “Definition of jug
    (Entry 1 of 2)
    1a(1) : a large deep container (as of glass, earthenware, or plastic) with a narrow mouth and a handle
    (2) : the contents of such a container : jugful
    b chiefly British : a small pitcher
    2 : jail, prison
    jug
    verb
    jugged; jugging
    Definition of jug (Entry 2 of 2)
    transitive verb
    1 : to stew (something, such as a hare) in an earthenware vessel
    2 : jail, imprison”

    Since you were not jailed or imprisoned, what did you experience?

    http://notredameclassof1969blog.blogspot.com/2017/07/what-was-origin-of-jug-common.html

    https://www.ignatius.edu/news/september-2017/jug-em-with-a-jugum

    1. Ed: I agree. Many may not understand what I meant by jug. My autocorrect function keeps trying to change it to bug but in fighting that I just let it be.

      I looked up the definition and saw it referred to prison and hoped folk would understand it may have a meaning of some type of detention. I appreciate your clarification. Thanks.

      1. My best friend and his three brothers all went to Catholic Memorial. They were the first to use the word jug when talking about detention. I went to Milton High and we just called it detention. When I asked them what the word meant they just said, “That’s what the Brothers call it so that’s what we call it.” Maybe it is like being put in a jug and corked in there. I have at least 20 books on English word origins. I’ll see if it shows up in any of them.

Comments are closed.