What’s Going On? The Unwarranted Attack Against Prosecutors

I’m going back again at the Globe editorial demanding “prosecutors must answer for actions.”  Yesterday I mentioned it seemed to be an ill-timed intrusion into the governor’s race since nothing it called for needed immediate attention; also, that it twisted the event into one of prosecutorial misconduct when the real problem involved ineffective assistance of defense counsel.

The Globe conjured up the idea there was a problem when the basis upon which it relied showed there was no problem. It suggested there was prosecutorial misconduct when the evidence points to a prosecutor who did his job. It yelled out that the case was brought on “the skimpiest evidence” when the prosecutor was confronted with evidence from six children between the ages of two and four, three boys and three girls, indicating the defendant, Bernard F. Baran, Jr., molested them. I’ll talk more about the editorial tomorrow.

The editorial was based upon an op-ed in the same paper that disingenuously suggested there was a problem by using a quote from an Appeals Court decision that was contrary to the facts that exist. The author of that editorial, Harvey Silverglate, a defense lawyer who was involved in the matters surrounding the Fells Acre Day Care case, which he called a fraud upon the public justice, and the defendant Baran, as I said has an ax to grind. Like any defense lawyer he is interested in making the prosecutor’s job more difficult; or at least trying to cast doubt on the integrity of prosecutors.

Silverglate suggests Baran’s conviction was based on “arguable prosecutor misconduct.”  He suggests it was occasioned by the nationwide hysteria that existed in the 1980s over the allegations of sexual abuse of preschool children. That existed, no doubt. As I mentioned before allegations of such during that time came into the county where I worked as an ADA but quick and thorough investigations by our State Police and Sexual Assault investigators showed them to be unfounded.

There was one case during that time in our office that did involve the issue of sexual abuse of preschool children. In that case a mother murdered her child because she thought that child was being sexually abused and sought to spare her from further abuse. She was abetted in that belief by a psychologist caught up in the hysteria Silverglate mentioned.

The prosecutor in the Baran case had before him evidence from six children who Silverglate said “recited their by-then-practiced abuse narratives.” Silverglate points out there was evidence that contradicted the evidence from those children that was contained on video tapes. Those tapes were made available to the defense counsel by the prosecutor Daniel Ford who has become a Superior Court judge. The defense counsel decided not to make use of them but agrees that they were available.

Silverglate wrote at the time the Appeals Court could not determine if “Ford intentionally buried the exculpatory unedited tapes (which would be a constitutional violation of suppression of evidence). He wrote that while having in front of him a lawyer’s letter telling him such allegation was “absolutely incorrect” and that a transcript exists showing those tapes had been made available to defense counsel. Not willing to wait to see the transcript that made his allegations specious, Silverglate, with the Globe’s connivance, for the Globe also had the lawyer’s letter, published his op-ed.

There has been no wrongdoing yet Silverglate complains “Judge Ford has not been publicly investigated, much less removed from the bench for leading an unjust prosecution that ruined a young man’s life.” He calls for a public investigation by conjuring up problems that don’t exist. He wants “prosecutors to pay for, rather than benefit from, their actions” even though what was done in this case was entirely appropriate. He wants an “open file discovery” policy where “prosecutors share all filed with defense counsel.”  

This policy is already pretty much followed by prosecutors in Massachusetts. It was followed by Daniel Ford. Ask yourself, what is a prosecutor to do with evidence from six children in front of him that a person molested them?

The real complaint in the Baran case is that the defense attorney should have done a better job. Turning his failure into a public inquisition of a prosecutor’s actions, or prosecutors in general, tells me something is going on in the background that is being hidden.  This matter bears very close scrutiny.


  1. [url=http://www.ooobrand.com/bags/hermes/642.html]スーパーコピーブランド完璧な品質●在庫情報随時更新!(*^-^*)S/SS品質 シリアル付きも有り付属品完備! 全物品運賃無料(日本全国)不良品物情況、無償で交換します.税関没収する商品は再度無料で発送します.安心して、安全に引き渡します.偽物カルティエスーパーコピー商品広大な客を歓迎して買います!ブランドバッグブランド財布ブランド腕時計[/url]

  2. [url=http://www.ooobag.com/wallet/louisvuitton/index_8.html]ルイヴィトン スーパーコピー「バッグ色は手触りがいいが、触ってみると、週囲の姉妹はこの綺麗、最近ずっと忙しくて、長い時間がかかりました、いい感じ ヴィトン スーパーコピー ルイヴィトンキーケース コピー当店ルイヴィトン 偽物は創業9年以上の老舗です。業界の長い歴史から言えばまだまだですが、創業 9 年以上の実績と信頼のあるお店です。全世界通信販売は6年前から行っております。さらに1年間で約数万件の販売実績があります。ルイヴィトン スーパーコピー 販売専門ショップです!ルイヴィトン コピー ブランドバッグ、財布、アクセサリー、手帳、ベルト、靴、腕時計、ネクタイ、スカーフなどを揃っております、日本国内最高級のルイヴィトン偽物ブランド激安販売![/url]

  3. [url=http://www.brandiwc.com/brand-super-12-copy-0.html]当店は信頼できるルイヴィトンスーパーコピーN級品販売店。100%実物写真ですし、品質が完璧です。高品質ルイヴィトンコピー,安全税関対策+素早い配送+随時の在庫補給+丁寧な対応+スーパーコピー販売業界最低価格に挑戦!ルイヴィトンスーパーコピー[/url]

  4. [url=http://www.bagkakaku.com/vuitton_wallet/wallet/146.html]コンスタンチンchaykinコンプトゥスの復活祭の時計は、あなたはそれを推測し、東方正教会の復活祭の感動的な日付を識別する顕著な挑戦に取り組むために設計されました。 パネライスーパーコピー このように、なぜ日付を計算するのが非常に難しいですか?さて、決定要因を含むので、月のサイクルは、太陽のサイクルは、エパクト、太陽の補正とより多く。chaykinのこれらの要因の全てを使用して計算をするために彼自身の方法を作成する方法を学びました、そして、彼だけにクロックを教えるように東方正教会の復活祭の日付を計算する。私たちはすぐにリストが無数の他の機能の中で、これはこの顕著な構造の目玉、大理石、真鍮、シルバー、鋼、ジュラルミン、ガラス、金、ラピスラズリ、とより多くから作られます。[/url]

  5. [url=http://www.eevance.com/tokei/vuitton/index.html]腕時計の後に(サファイア展の窓を通して)より完全なビューへの骨格化と装飾を処理します。私の考えでは非常に高級で上品な、ティソの最高の彫刻の線の部分の1つである。それはあなたが気にしない手巻き腕時計なら毎日でも着用者として適している。ルイ・ヴィトンコピー 私に明らかでありません、クロコダイルストラップがどのケースに合った1つのものである。若干のイメージに近い突起の間に座るより伝統的なまっすぐな端は、ケースに触れることはないのですが。他の画像において、それはケースの形状に適合するようにぴったりのストラップを使用しています。私はちょうど知りませんが、実際に使用されています。[/url]

  6. [url=http://www.eevance.com/tokei/chopard/index.html]およそ1年前、私は私のマーク・カーソンkaラ・スポーツ腕時計はどうなるのだろう、ダイヤルと手を設計したが、特定の思想は当時のストラップに与えられました。私は、バーゼル2015年から帰ったとき、私は座った一つのゴールの設計は、高セキュリティストラップシステムを利用することができたのは、曲がった金属片の「私のマーク・カーソンkaラの場合にnatoストラップのより多くの保安を提供するツールと特徴的なマッチョの観察を提供する。[/url]